Positive Parenting Newsfeed—a Child Trends Project—is Supported by the National Science Foundation

Too Much Structured Playtime

SEATTLE, Wash. (Ivanhoe Newswire) — We’ve all seen it. Maybe we’re guilty ourselves of being parents who want their kids in every lesson and on every team. But we may not be doing kids any favors, as far as helping them develop what’s called self-directed executive function. That means setting a goal and independently figuring out how to reach it.

Jennifer Loomis sometimes struggles as a mom not to over plan five-year-old Morrison’s free time.

“Then our children don’t get the opportunity to become independent, in a way, and they look to the tall people in their lives to tell them what to do next,” Jennifer told Ivanhoe.

Jane Barker’s research at the University of Colorado-Boulder showed a similar outcome. Her team studied 67 six-year-old children and their families. Mom and dad reported what the kids did all week while the kids took verbal fluency tests to gauge their self-directed executive function.

“We gave them a category, such as foods, and then we ask them to name as many foods as they can in a one-minute period,” explained Barker.

Children with good executive function sub-categorize their food list, say by vegetables, or breakfast food, or fruit. Barker said the kids who did better on these tests were the kids with more free time.

“We typically don’t provide instructions for people on how to solve it and produce a lot of words, but we do see this sort of spontaneous self-directed organizational activity,” detailed Barker.

Barker said we need follow-up studies but making more time for unstructured activities, such as going to the park or zoo, reading, or free play.

It’s important to note that the six-year-olds in this study were from affluent families. Previous studies have found that children from low-income households may be less likely to have access to programs and would be more likely to benefit from structured activities.

Contributors to this news report include: Cyndy McGrath, Supervising Producer; Wendy Choiji, Field Producer; Ken Ashe, Editor; Rusty Reed, Videographer.

Produced by Child Trends News Service in partnership with Ivanhoe Broadcast News and funded by a grant from the National Science Foundation.

(Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4060299/)

facebook twitter instagram tiktok youtube arrow up Play Icon Envelope Arrow Right Arrow Down